FGV 2024.1Questão 36de 60According to the information in the passage, which of the following is most likely a reason that Sergio Massa lost the
InglêsInterpretação de texto
Texto das questões 35 a 37
Texto para as perguntas de 35 a 37
MILEI’S VICTORY
By
Tony Wood
(Note: The following passage [trecho] was taken and adapted from an article that was completed on 1 December 2023, shortly after Javier Milei won Argentina’s presidential election.)
1 On 10 December, the far-right libertarian economist Javier Milei will take office as Argentina’s president. To say that his victory in November’s elections was a shock would be an understatement. A few months ago, people who thought that Milei might become the next occupant of the Casa Rosada, the presidential palace, were largely dismissed as delusional. Widely known as “El Loco” – the Madman – Milei became a TV personality in the mid-2010s, earning renown for his unhinged tirades [tiradas desequilibradas] against everything from feminism to climate change. He wants to legalize the carrying of guns, recriminalize abortion, and abolish Argentina’s Central Bank. A former sex guru and front man [líder e porta-voz] for a Rolling Stones cover band, the mop-haired [de cabelo desgrenhado] Milei has many well-known eccentricities. He claims to commune with his deceased dog though a spirit medium, and that four of the dogs he expensively cloned from the original pet offer him expert political and economic advice.
2 Yet considering that the left-wing Peronist party has been in power for sixteen of the last twenty years and has left Argentina in shambles [em frangalhos, em confusão], one doesn’t have to look far to find reasons why Milei defeated Sergio Massa by a huge margin (56 per cent of the vote to Massa’s 44) in the second round [segundo turno] of the election. As minister of the economy for the ruling Peronist coalition, Massa presided over an upward spiral of inflation, now at 143 percent, which has wreaked havoc [causou estragos] on most people’s capacity to make ends meet [fazer face às despesas]. Forty percent of the population are below the official poverty line; among those aged sixteen and under, the figure is 57 percent.
3 Moreover, the support of the established center-right and right-wing parties was another critical factor in Milei’s success. Mauricio Macri, who served as a center-right president from 2015 to 2019, was openly in favor of Milei’s candidacy. In a radio interview on 27 October, Macri used a hair-raising [arrepiante] analogy to describe the options facing Argentina in the November run-off [segundo (último) turno]. “You’re driving at 100 [km per hour], you’re going to hit a wall and you know that you’ll die, so you throw yourself from the car.” For Macri, a Peronist victory was the wall and voting for Milei was the last-ditch dive [a última oportunidade para se jogar] onto the asphalt. “Will you survive?” he asked. “I don’t know, but you have a chance, right?”
4 On 19 November, Argentinians opted to throw themselves out of the moving car.
Adapted from the London Review of Books, December 14, 2023.
According to the information in the passage, which of the following is most likely a reason that Sergio Massa lost the election?
- Alternativa A: Javier Milei has better economic advisors.
- Alternativa B: The Peronist coalition was so incompetent and unpredictable that no one had any idea of what to expect from a Massa government.
- Alternativa C: The Peronist coalition was not just incompetent, it was also astonishingly corrupt.
- Alternativa D, a correta: During Sergio Massa’s time as minister of the economy, children and young people especially suffered.Resposta
- Alternativa E: Sergio Massa’s time as minister of the economy coincided with the worst period of inflation in Argentina’s history.
A questão pede uma razão provável para a derrota de Sergio Massa, segundo o texto.
Localizando os dados do parágrafo 2:
Massa foi ministro da Economia e presidiu uma espiral de inflação, hoje em 143%, que arrasou a capacidade das pessoas de fechar as contas. E vêm os dois números: "Forty percent of the population are below the official poverty line; among those aged sixteen and under, the figure is 57 percent."
Interpretando o contraste entre os dois números:
A pobreza atinge 40% da população em geral, mas 57% entre os que têm até dezesseis anos. Ou seja, crianças e jovens foram atingidos de forma DESPROPORCIONAL, sofreram especialmente, que é o que a alternativa correta afirma.
Analisando as demais alternativas:
A alternativa sobre Milei ter melhores assessores econômicos não aparece no texto, o que aparece são os cachorros clonados dando conselhos.
A alternativa sobre imprevisibilidade do peronismo não é o argumento do texto, que fala em resultados concretos, não em incerteza.
A alternativa sobre corrupção surpreendente não é mencionada: o texto fala em incompetência econômica, nunca em corrupção.
A alternativa que diz ser o pior período de inflação da HISTÓRIA argentina extrapola: o texto dá o número de 143%, sem compará-lo com outras épocas, e a Argentina já teve hiperinflação bem pior.
Conferindo a alternativa:
A razão apoiada pelos dados corresponde à alternativa D.
Confere com o gabarito oficial da FGV. Ver o caderno da banca
